Thelma & Louise: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray)

Two best friends set out on an adventure, but it soon turns around to a terrifying escape from being hunted by the police, as these two girls escape for the crimes they committed.

May 9, 2023 10 Min Read

Review by: Matt Brighton

Plot: What’s it about?

I had just graduated from High School in May of 1991 and was at a CD shop (you don’t see those much anymore, do you?) I came across the soundtrack for a then “new” movie called Thelma & Louise. I tend to judge books, or in this case, CD’s by their cover so I instantly labeled this as a chick flick. I mean, let’s face it, a Polaroid of two women in a convertible? Chick flick. About a week or so later, I actually made it to the theater and figured that I’d see the movie as it was directed by Ridley Scott. Scott, at the time, had directed several films and Alien was among them. I figured any person who could go from sci-fi horror movie to chick flick certainly merited my $5. As it stands, Thelma & Louise was one of the most critically-acclaimed films of 1991 and remains one of my favorite movies. And I’ve seen a lot of movies. Ironically enough, the film might be best known for introducing us to an up and coming young actor by the name of Brad Pitt. Heard of him? Turns out his future was bright.

Louise (Susan Sarandon) has had a tough life. She’s a waitress at a local coffee shop and has planned to go on a weekend getaway with her best friend, Thelma (Geena Davis). Thelma is the yin to Louise’s yang and lives in pseudo fear of her husband, an all-talk but no action couch potato by the name of Darryl (Christopher MacDonald). The girls enjoy their time away, but Thelma is assaulted in the parking lot of a bar. Louise shoots and kills the potential rapist and the two make a quick getaway. From this point forward the movie becomes a cat and mouse game. The FBI is brought in to help catch the ladies and is led by Hal (Harvey Keitel). As Thelma and Louise continue to avoid the long arm of the law, their relationship grows. Along the way they meet a drifter by the name of J.D. (Brad Pitt) whose good looks mask his ulterior motives. Time, though, is running out and Thelma and Louise must decide to surrender to the officials or keep going. If life is about the journey and not the destination, then “Thelma & Louise” celebrates life.

Don’t make the same mistake that I did. Don’t judge a book by its cover. Yes, on the surface, Thelma & Louise might look like a typical chick movie and I suppose in some aspects it is. But there are some deeper issues at play in the film and rape and murder are just a couple of the issues tackled. Apart from the two leads, Harvey Keitel, Christopher MacDonald and Harvey Keitel offer some great supporting roles and as we’ve discussed, Brad Pitt used this movie to catapult his career into superstardom. When you look back at the films of Ridley Scott, a few will stand out and as talented a director as he is, I’d put Thelma & Louise near (if not at) the top of that list. It’s hard to believe that it’s been two decades since this film first hit theaters, so if it’s been a while since you’ve seen it or never have had the pleasure – it’s worth the journey.

Video: How does it look?

It’s been just a shade over a decade since the last Blu-ray of this film was released. Criterion’s new Blu-ray features a wide picture with a new AVC HD transfer that celebrates the landscape of the southwest. A majority of the film takes place outside, so we see the dark blue sky contrasted with the orangish-brown mountains of East Texas and Arizona. Flesh tones are on par, though some scenes tend to be a bit on the warmer side. Detail has been bumped up a notch or two from the previous release, but not to the point where it looks fake. Contrast and black levels are both right on the mark. I know I sound like a broken record, but Thelma & Louise has never looked better.

Audio: How does it sound?

On the audio front, we get a new DTS HD Master Audio soundtrack that breathes new life into the old Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack. By and large the movie is dialogue-driven, but the soundtrack does take hold at certain points and the ending B.B. King song “Better Not Look Down” has never sounded better. There are a few directional effects, a few shots fired that’s to say, that are an improvement as well. The movie has a nice, solid soundtrack that sounds as good as ever on this new Blu-ray.

Supplements: What are the extras?

Disc One (Blu-ray)

  • Audio Commentary – Originally recorded in 1996, director Ridley Scott covers a lot of aspects about the shoot, casting and the overall theme of the film. Scott gives some pretty informative tracks.
  • Audio Commentary – Recorded in 2001 for the film’s DVD release, we’ve got actresses Susan Sarandon and Geena Davis joined by Callie Khouri. This track is a little more dead, with the actresses kind of watching what goes on during the movie, but not offering that much in return. If you have a choice, go with Scott’s track.
  • Ridley Scott: Beginnings – In this new segment, Ridley Scott gives us an overview of his career and his initial interest in Thelma & Louise. Running just over 20 minutes it’s informative and interesting – I’d have liked to see more.
  • Short Films – Some of Ridley Scott’s early work is profiled with a 30 minute movie as well as a one minute beer commercial.
    • Boy and Bicycle
    • Ploughman
  • Callie Khouri – Screenwriter Callie Khouri, who won the film’s only Oscar for Best Original Screenplay, is profiled about her approach to the script and so forth.

Disc Two (Blu-ray)

  • Thelma & Louise: The Last Journey – Produced in 2001, this three-part documentary has just about anything and everything that a fan of the film could need or want. Interviews with the cast and crew shed some light on the overall production.
  • Original Theatrical Featurette – Just that. A six minute “vintage” featurette that has some talking heads and whatnot.
  • Extended Scenes – Just over 30 minutes’ worth of extended scenes. Given that the film was already 130 minutes long, these were trimmed down.
  • Deleted Scenes – A nice compliment to the above feature with 15 minutes (10 scenes) that were ultimately left on the cutting room floor.
  • Storyboards: The Final Chase – Again, this is pretty self-explanatory. We get a breakdown of the film’s climatic scene.
  • Publicity Materials – Posters, TV spots and trailers.
  • Music Video – “Part of Me, Part of You” by Glenn Frey.
  • Illustrated Booklet – Critics Jessica Kiang and Rachel Syme and journalist Rebecca Traister offer their input in this staple of Criterion’s discs.

The Bottom Line

Thelma & Louise is widely-regarded as one of Ridley Scott’s better films and that’s saying a lot considering those he’s directed. The film was nominated for half a dozen Academy Awards ultimately only winning one (Best Original Screenplay) major one that Silence of the Lambs didn’t pick up. You can call it a chick flick if you want, but there’s much more below the surface. Criterion’s new disc offers up a new feature, an improved picture and a slew of supplements. Fans will want this one in their collection.

Disc Scores